The Catholic League for Religious and Civil Rights claims that what Kathy Griffin said at the Creative Arts Emmys amounts to hate speech. My first thought was “Wow, only a rich head of a religious organization who wants to get plenty of PR so that his membership believes he’s a git-r-done kind of guy would label this as hate speech.”
But then I realized the tragedy of this situation: Catholic League president Bill Donohue has no sense of humor. It’s probably not his fault. How can I sit idly by while Bill wastes away, his heart a lump of rigid, humorless coal?
So Bill – please read on. And get ready to laugh!!
Hate speech is defined thusly:
hate speech n. – Bigoted speech attacking or disparaging a social or ethnic group or a member of such a group.
Here is Griffin’s speech:
“A lot of people come up here and thank Jesus for this award.1 I want you to know that no one had less to do with this award than Jesus.2 Suck it, Jesus.3 This award is my god now.”4
Now let’s take this line by line and I’ll explain why this is funny, even to me, a professed Christian.
1 – Griffin lays down the premise, and it’s a fact: a lot of people do go to the podium and thank God or Jesus for their award. At this point the audience member will think to himself “Yes, I recognize that as being true. I can relate to the person telling this story.”
2 – Here Griffin gives us the first twist of the joke – she believes that Jesus had nothing to do with her award. This is classic comedy – the humor comes from unexpected turns in the development of the story, surprising the audience, resulting in laughter.
3 – This is the shockline of the joke. She says “Suck it, Jesus” the way sports fans might say “Suck it, 49ers! The Bears are #1!” The reason this line is funny is because Jesus is a sacred and revered entity and in polite company, one doesn’t say things like this to Jesus.
4 – As a bonus, we get shockline #2: the statue is her god now. A ridiculous notion and a line that is consistant with Griffin’s persona. The audience thinks “That’s preposterous! She wouldn’t really worship an Emmy, would she? How outrageous!” and this will normally lead to peels of raucous laughter.
Look closely, Bill, and you’ll see that not only is this speech funny, it attacks no one. It is bigoted in no way whatsoever. It is not hate speech. Now if you were to say “The gay community has yet to apologize to straight people for all the damage that they have done.” or that “Hollywood is controlled by secular Jews who hate Christianity in general and Catholicism in particular. It’s not a secret, okay? And I’m not afraid to say it. … Hollywood likes anal sex.”, that would be closer to the hate speech ballpark.
In fact, by being insulting to Jesus, Griffin is acknowledging Jesus’stature. This joke would not be funny if people didn’t think Jesus was generally a great figure worthy of respect.
Isn’t that fun, now, Bill? Isn’t it fun to laugh? Of course it is. See? It’s okay. You can believe and have fun at the same time! In the future it might be interesting to think through these matters before blabbing all over the media like some PR-hungry profit-making corporation. Remember: you believe in Jesus Christ and Jesus Christ can not be defeated, even by an omnipotent D-list celebrity.
—
This is a separate post for Kathy Griffin only:
Apologies are death. No retreat, no surrender!
tags: