The following review is written as part of the Final Girl Film Club.
Somewhere inside the movie “John Carpenter’s Prince of Darkness” is the moment when the John Carpenter who made “Halloween” ends and the John Carpenter who made “Ghosts of Mars” begins. I’m not positive what that moment is, but it involves this guy:

And that’s not to say Jameson Parker, playing college student Brian Marsh, is a poor actor. Instead, he exemplifies everything that’s right and wrong about “Prince of Darkness”. On the right side, he’s a low key, believable dude, hip enough to gain our sympathy and square enough to be a one of a handful collegiate, meta-physics nerds. On the wrong side, the mustache. Porn-era facial hair is always welcome in a B-grade horror movie, but this story aspires to something better that it never really becomes.
[WARNING: This review will spoil just about everything.]
The story breaks down like this: A priest dies, leaving behind a box with a key inside. The key is passed to Father Loomis (Donald Pleasance, of course), who also looks through the priest’s diary (not cool, Loomis). In it are writings that portend a coming evil – “The sleeper awakens.” and “I have witnessed His stirrings.”, etc. Why the priest must wax poetic and can’t just write “The devil is coming! Satan, I’m talking about. Run!” I’m not sure, but it does move the plot along.
Father Loomis heads to the nearby college where Professor Birack is holding court with his class, talking about how logic breaks down at the sub-atomic level and while I want to write “blah-dy, blah-dy, blah” at the end of this sentence, I have to admit that the conversation had me somewhat intrigued. It was a simple set up, I guess; the idea that what we perceive as time and space isn’t necessarily true and that there are plenty of things we don’t understand going on under our noses all the time. Neat.
So Loomis talks to Birack about the key, the priest, the sleeper awakening and so on, and the two head to the church where our dead, poetic priest used to hang. It’s filled with a million candles, a dusty ol’ book of important writings, and a big tube of swirly green evil.
Next thing you know, Birack rounds up some students (including Brian and totally hot science-nerd Catherine (who DO IT almost immediately), each with their own area of expertise in the various sciences and moves them into the church to investigate. Computers are set up, technical jargon is thrown around, and we discover that there are two – count ‘em, TWO – members of great 80s TV – Parker (seen above) of ‘Simon & Simon’ fame, and Thom Bray, known to most people as the “Boz” from ‘Riptide’. Sweet.
A translation of the big ol’ dusty book reveals passages much more straightforward than the dead priest could probably handle – “And the Prince of Darkness was Himself sealed, that old life, called the Devil and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world” – and characters exchange worried looks. Worms crawl up windows. More worried looks. Then the “Boz” get impaled on a broken bicycle by Alice Cooper (followed around by an eerie army of the homeless) and all hell starts to break loose. A girl is possessed by devil water and starts killing her classmates. A bearded dude says the whole operation is “caca” – seriously, he says “caca” – then gets knifed about 50 times by a bag lady. Somewhere in here, Brian and Catherine continue to make googly eyes at each other.
Through all these rote (though well handled) 80s horror hijinx, we get one sweet morsel of creativity – the dreams. Our heroes start having dreams that look like a video of the front of the church. In the doorway is a figure, persumably Satan or someone similarly evil, and a voice warns that this is an image of what is to come, that this transmission had to be sent as a dream.
Wow.
Video footage of the devil sent through time to your dreams is way, way cool. Worms on windows and dudes saying “caca” is effin’ ridiculous.
Things progress from here in a fairly predictable manner – more people are possessed, more people die and the students become increasingly convinced that they’re dealing with something big and evil. Then comes one of my favorite lines in the movie – “Caca” guy comes back from the dead as a suit filled with bugs and says this – “I have a message for you. You’re not going to like it.” What an awesome understatement.
More water gets squirted around, one lady turns into sort of the lead evil character and develops a serious bout of pizza face and… man… I start getting bored at this point. I’m not sure what it is exactly, but I feel like the movie isn’t building on anything. I feel like maybe we’ve reached that sub-atomic level of filmmaking at this point, and all logic has broken down. Mirrors become the portal from which whatever it is is going to enter our world. All the unpossessed people are fighting possessed people. And Pizza Face reaches into a big mirror and starts pulling out a big demonic hand. Catherine sees this and loses it, blitzing evil through the mirror, back into its own dimension.
And after 100 or so minutes of veering madly from terrible lameness to super cool creep out, we come upon the moment that, I think, used up all that Carpenter had left in his big bag of awesome – Father Loomis hurls an ax at the mirror, smashing it. Then on the other side of the mirror, we see this:

Catherine, reaching back for the light of the real world as it flickers out and leaves her on the other side, forever. It is one of the eeriest images in film and I wonder now if this image wasn’t the image in Carpenter’s head when he first came up with this whole idea. It would make sense – it is so strong it nearly stands up all on its own. In most movies I feel like they wouldn’t have even bothered with this shot. She would’ve just disappeared never to be seen again and we would sympathize with Brian for losing his girl (which would be totally beside the point, but all about the usual formula (which the movie slips into anyway in its last two scenes)).
Finally, the movie winds down, showing the dream/video again, only this time the form in the doorway is Catherine. I’m not sure if that means she’s saved us (I think so) or if now she is the embodiment of evil (why not?). Then there are a couple of jump scares and we’re off into the credits.
There’s a lot that’s predictable and sloppy about “Prince of Darkness”, but there’s plenty that still seems fresh, too. I’ve seen this movie probably 4 or 5 times since I was a kid and each time I expect it to be better than it is. Of course, it’s not, but maybe someday if I ever reach that sub-atomic level of watching movies, then blah-dy, blah-dy, blah.
tags: